Thursday, December 17, 2015

Star Trek: By Any Other Name

2015 is rapidly drawing to a close and I haven't had much time for blogging this year. I had more than twice as many posts in 2014 (87) than I've had so far in 2015 (this is # 41). Of course there are reasons for that - I moved to a new state, started a new job and then moved again (into a wonderful home in the country!).

I've got some free time here at the end of the year, so that means I've also got some blogging time too.

This week saw the first teaser trailer release for next summer's Star Trek Beyond, making this is a good time to ignore that awful looking Trek and instead talk about everything that's wonderful about the classic Star Trek series. I've been blogging about each episode (in production order), and have only covered seven episodes this year, so it's well past time to do another.

The next one in line is the second season episode (and 50th over all) known as:
By Any Other Name has got a going for it and I like it much more now than I did when I was younger. The episode takes a look at what it means to be human and what it would be like to have to deal with experiencing emotions and physical sensations for the very first time.
We begin with Kirk and a landing party beaming down to respond to a distress call. Alas, it is a trap and everyone is quickly paralyzed by Rojan of Kelva (center, above), who tells them basically that he's the new sheriff in town: "Any efforts to resist us or to escape will be severely punished. Soon we, and you, will leave this galaxy forever. You humans must face the end of your existence as you have known it."


The Kelvans intend to steal the Enterprise and use it to  take them back to their home in the Andromeda Galaxy (aka M31).  As Rojan explains, "Within ten millennia, high radiation levels in our galaxy will make life there impossible. So the Kelvan Empire sent forth ships to explore other galaxies, to search for one which our race could conquer and occupy." They've decided that the Milky Way will do nicely, so they've got to head home & let everyone know.

For me, the concept of the high radiation levels in M31 is a very interesting idea, one that mirrors some of the writing in Larry Niven's Known Space series (see his 1966 story At The Core), in which an alien race is fleeing the Milky Way because of radiation from an outward-spreading wave of supernova explosions taking place in our galaxy's core.

A modern image of starburst galaxy M82 from the Hubble Space Telescope
These similar ideas likely owe their genesis in the real life astronomical research of Allan Sandage, who in the early 1960s was studying a galaxy known as M82 with the then biggest telescope on the planet, the 200-inch Hale Telescope at Palomar Observatory. We now refer to M82 as a starburst galaxy (nothing to do with candy), but seeing gas rushing outward from the galaxy itself, Sandage interpreted the observations as M82 being a galaxy that was exploding. It was a popular idea that likely influenced both Niven and Jerome Bixby who gave us the initial story for By Any Other Name. But I digress...
Just after the opening credits roll Rojan's lackeys make quick work of taking over the Enterprise and they are making preparations for heading back to M31. They plan on modifying the engines to make the 2.5 million light year journey in just 300 years. It will be a multi generational trip for them, which is odd, since we never see more than maybe a dozen Kelvans in all.

The Kelvans need the Enterprise because their ship was destroyed crossing the Milky Way's energy barrier, which was a plot device in Trek's second pilot, Where No Man Has Gone Before. By the way, the energy barrier turns up again (!) in the third season episode Is There In Truth No Beauty?

Spock asks Rojan, why don't they just send a message back home instead of stealing the Enterprise and Rojan explains that "No form of transmission can penetrate the barrier," which is odd since, you know, we can see the Andromeda galaxy. Spock should know that light in all its forms (visible, radio waves, etc.) penetrate the barrier just fine. Maybe the barrier just blocks "subspace," whatever that is.

Oh, well. Rojan and the other Kelvans imprison the landing party and then explain how eager they'll be to get off of the planet and back into space.
While behind bars, Spock offers some instant metallurgy, describing the metal bars "Fascinating material. Similar to diburnium, but considerably more dense. I doubt even phaser fire could disturb its molecular structure." I'm not really sure how he can tell all that from just pinging on the bars, but then I'm not a Vulcan science officer, am I.

While they're imprisoned, Kirk makes a reference to an earlier episode (A Taste of Armageddon) - something that is just about unheard of in classic Trek. It's where Spock used his mental abilities to try to persuade a guard to open the door. Maybe he could try it again here...
Spock makes the attempt and then is thrown backward.
Spock later explains what he sensed during his brief mental contact with a Kelvan: "A series of bizarre and exotic images bursting on my mind and consciousness. Colors, shapes, mathematical equations fused and blurred. I've been attempting to isolate them, but so far I've been able to recall clearly only one. Immense beings, a hundred limbs which resemble tentacles. Minds of such control and capacity that each limb is capable of performing a different function."
Because of their escape attempt Rojan demonstrates another of his somewhat magical abilities, by reducing two members of the landing party into little 10-sided sponges. He explains, "This is the essence of what they were. The flesh and brain and what you call the personality, distilled down into these compact shapes."
 To further demonstrate, Rojan crushes one of them (killing the yeoman) and then restores the other one.
Realizing that he's not getting anywhere here, Kirk asks Spock to fake an illness so that he and McCoy can be beamed aboard the Enterprise. Spock puts himself into a trance, which Vulcans find to be "more restful to the body than your so-called vacation." Clearly Vulcans need to get out more often.

The whole effort is a bit of a waste, as the Kelvins soon want them aboard the starship anyway, as they make their way through the energy barrier at the edge of the galaxy.
Spock and Scotty have cooked up a way to stop the Kelvans by destroying the Enterprise when they cross the energy barrier. Kirk calls them "Mad."
Nevertheless, Scotty's ready and has his finger on the button as they recycle old footage from Where No Man Has Gone Before on their way out of the Milky Way.
The above shot in particular is embarrassingly bad. I know they were on a budget.
As a reward for sitting through that, we do get to see the Enterprise swooshing off towards the Andromeda Galaxy, which almost makes it all okay. I am happy that the effects crew (or somebody giving them direction) was smart enough to know that there aren't really stars between galaxies and they left the rest of the sky appropriately empty. Nice.
The real downer is that once they've crossed the energy barrier, to save on consumables, the crew gets reduced to 10-sided sponges with just Kirk, Spock, McCoy & Scotty left behind to save the day.
The gang is having a bite of colored food cubes (Yum!) when when of the Kelvans (Tomar) approaches wanting to know what all the fuss is about, saying "I do not understand why you take the trouble to consume this bulk material to sustain yourselves." McCoy suggests that he give it a try and he likes it.

Spock tells us that "The Kelvans have superior intellectual capacity. To achieve it, they have apparently sacrificed anything which would tend to distract them. Perceptive senses such as taste, touch, smell, and, of course, emotions... they have taken human form and are therefore having human reactions."

So maybe they can use that as an advantage and get the Kelvans to lower their guard.  
It's Green.
This leads to Scotty suggesting that Tomar will need something to wash his food down and a classic drinking match ensues. Scotty starts him off in the Rec Hall with Saurian Brandy and then they move to his quarters for more.

Later, when Scotty fetches a new bottle and when Tomar asks what is it, Scotty gives a classic reply:

The line was good  enough that when James Doohan appeared as Scotty on an episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation (Relics) they used it again.
Scotty finally drinks Tomar under the table with his "very, very, very old Scotch whisky." It's really quite wonderful.
Meanwhile, in an effort to make Rojan jealous, Kirk is putting the moves on Kelinda. She clearly likes it and, as expected, Rojan doesn't like her kissing Kirk.
Kirk explains it all to Rojan: "Look what's happened in the short time you've been exposed to us. What do you think will happen in three centuries? When this ship gets to Kelva, the people on it will be human. They'll be aliens. Enemies!"

Rojan goes on about his mission, but Kirk offers that the Federation can help them find new worlds to live on. Rojan counters with "You would really do that? You would extend welcome to invaders?"

Kirk's reply: "No. But we would welcome friends." And that's what Star Trek is all about, Charlie Brown.

Kalinda and Rojan kiss, Kirk explains that there are certain advantages in being human, like "being able to appreciate the beauty of a flower and a beautiful woman." Wink. Wink.

Rojan turns command back over to Kirk and they head back home.

Composer Fred Steiner wrote about 12 and a half minutes of music for this episode, which included a theme for the Kelvans and a short motif used whenever they activated their Neutralizers. It all works nicely in the episode.

Next up, Return to Tomorrow.

1 comment: